What Happens If the Stock Market Crashes Right After You Retire?
Imagine spending 40 years saving for retirement.
You've built a $1.5 million portfolio, paid down your mortgage, picked your retirement date, and you're finally ready to walk away from your last day of work.
Then, six months after you retire, the stock market crashes.
Your $1.5 million portfolio falls 25% and is suddenly worth approximately $1.125 million. At the same time, you no longer have a paycheck coming in and need to begin withdrawing money from your investments to pay your bills.
Is your retirement ruined? Do you need to go back to work? Should you stop taking withdrawals? Or should you sell before the market falls even further?
Not necessarily.
A stock market crash right after retirement can be particularly damaging, but it doesn't automatically mean your retirement plan has failed.
The bigger issue is something known as sequence of returns risk.
Understanding this risk—and preparing for it before you retire—can make an enormous difference in your ability to withstand the next bear market.
Here are five strategies I believe retirees should consider when preparing their portfolios for a potential stock market crash.
Why Is a Stock Market Crash More Dangerous After Retirement?
A falling stock market isn't necessarily bad news when you're still accumulating money for retirement.
If you're 45 years old and regularly contributing to your 401(k), lower stock prices allow your contributions to purchase more shares.
You also have something extremely valuable:
Time.
If you're 10, 15, or 20 years away from retirement, you may have years for your investments to recover before you need the money.
Retirement changes that equation.
Once your paycheck stops, your investment portfolio may become one of your primary sources of retirement income.
Instead of regularly putting money into your portfolio, you're now regularly taking money out.
A stock market crash can therefore create two problems at the same time:
Your investments are declining in value.
You're withdrawing money from those investments.
That's where sequence of returns risk becomes particularly important.
What Is Sequence of Returns Risk?
Sequence of returns risk is the danger that poor investment returns occur at the wrong time—particularly during the first several years of retirement when you're simultaneously withdrawing money from your portfolio.
Consider two hypothetical retirees.
Both retire at age 65 with:
$1.5 million
Both withdraw the same amount each year.
And over their retirements, both portfolios experience the same average investment return.
There's only one difference.
Retiree A experiences strong stock market returns during the first several years of retirement and poor returns later.
Retiree B experiences a major market decline immediately after retiring, followed by stronger returns later.
Even though their average investment returns could ultimately be similar, their retirement outcomes can be dramatically different.
Why?
Because they're withdrawing money along the way.
When Retiree B sells investments while the portfolio is down, those shares are permanently removed from the portfolio.
When the market eventually recovers, fewer shares remain to participate in that recovery.
That's the essence of sequence of returns risk.
An Example of Sequence of Returns Risk in Retirement
Let's assume you retire with:
$1,500,000
You plan to withdraw:
$75,000 per year
Initially, that's a:
5% annual withdrawal
Now imagine the stock market falls 25% shortly after you retire.
Your $1.5 million portfolio falls to approximately:
$1,125,000
But you still need $75,000 to fund your lifestyle.
That same $75,000 withdrawal now represents approximately:
6.67% of your reduced portfolio.
If you're forced to sell depreciated investments to generate that income, you're locking in losses and leaving less money invested for a future recovery.
And if the market decline lasts several years, the problem can compound.
This is why the first several years of retirement can be such an important period for retirement-income planning.
Can You Predict the Next Stock Market Crash?
No one consistently knows when the next stock market crash will occur.
You can listen to market forecasts, economists, investment strategists, television personalities, and financial commentators, but no one can reliably tell you exactly when the next bear market will begin or end.
That's why I don't believe your retirement strategy should depend on correctly predicting the market.
Instead of asking:
“When will the stock market crash?”
Ask:
“What happens to my retirement plan if the stock market crashes?”
Those are very different questions.
One requires predicting the future.
The other requires preparing for it.
You may not be able to control what the stock market does during your first year of retirement, but you can control how your portfolio and retirement-income strategy are prepared for it.
Here are five strategies to consider.
1. Maintain Short-Term Investments for Retirement Withdrawals
One of the biggest problems during a bear market is being forced to sell stocks after they've fallen significantly.
One potential solution is maintaining a portion of your portfolio in investments that aren't as dependent on stock market performance.
Depending on your circumstances and risk tolerance, this could include:
Cash
Money market funds
Short-term bonds
Short-term CDs
Other relatively conservative investments
The objective isn't necessarily to maximize the return on this portion of your portfolio.
It's to create a source of money you can potentially use for retirement expenses when stocks are down.
Instead of selling stocks after a major decline, you may be able to temporarily fund some of your withdrawals from your more conservative investments while giving the stock portion of your portfolio more time to recover.
How much should you maintain?
There's no universal answer.
In the example from my podcast, I discuss considering approximately five to ten years of anticipated portfolio withdrawals in more conservative investments, depending on your circumstances and tolerance for risk.
But this isn't a rule that will be appropriate for every retiree.
Your appropriate amount depends on your overall portfolio, guaranteed income, spending requirements, risk tolerance, time horizon, and other financial resources.
The important point is to have a plan before the market falls.
2. Review Your Asset Allocation Before You Retire
If you're five years away from retirement, your investment strategy deserves a fresh look.
A portfolio designed for a 45-year-old accumulating retirement savings may not necessarily be appropriate for a 65-year-old who is about to begin withdrawing from those savings.
That doesn't mean retirees should eliminate stocks.
Stocks can continue to play an important role in providing the long-term growth needed for a portfolio to keep pace with inflation and support potentially decades of retirement spending.
But you need to understand how much risk you're actually taking.
Ask yourself:
If my portfolio fell 20%, what would I do?
What about 25%?
What if the decline were 30%?
And don't think only in percentages.
Convert that percentage into dollars.
If you have a $2 million retirement portfolio, a 25% decline represents:
$500,000
Watching $500,000 disappear from your account statements can feel very different from hearing someone casually discuss a “25% market correction.”
Understanding your potential downside before retirement can help you build a portfolio you're more likely to stick with when markets become volatile.
Click here to get your FREE electronic copy of:
Fiduciary - How to Find, Hire, and Establish an Aligned Trusted Partnership with a Fee-Only Financial Advisor
Your Portfolio Should Match Your Retirement Plan
Your appropriate asset allocation should reflect more than your age.
It should consider factors such as:
Retirement spending needs
Social Security income
Pension income
Required portfolio withdrawals
Time horizon
Risk tolerance
Tax situation
Other assets
Legacy goals
For example, imagine you need $100,000 per year from a $2 million portfolio.
If you decided you wanted approximately five years of those withdrawals in conservative investments, that would represent approximately $500,000.
The remaining $1.5 million could potentially remain invested for longer-term growth.
That's simply an illustration—not a recommended allocation for every retiree.
The broader point is that your retirement portfolio should be intentionally designed around the income you expect to need from it.
3. Keep Some of Your Retirement Spending Flexible
Your investment portfolio isn't the only part of your retirement plan that can adjust during a market downturn.
Your spending can sometimes adjust too.
One exercise I like for retirees is separating expenses into two categories:
Essential Expenses
These are expenses you generally can't eliminate, such as:
Housing
Property taxes
Utilities
Food
Insurance
Healthcare
Basic transportation
Discretionary Expenses
These might include:
Travel
Country club memberships
Boating
Entertainment
Large recreational purchases
Other lifestyle spending
You don't necessarily need to stop enjoying retirement simply because stocks decline.
But knowing how much of your spending is flexible gives you another lever you can pull during an extended bear market.
Dynamic Withdrawals Can Help During a Market Crash
Suppose you normally withdraw $75,000 annually from your portfolio.
If your portfolio experiences a significant decline, temporarily reducing discretionary spending could allow you to decrease that withdrawal.
That leaves more money invested.
It can also reduce the percentage of your remaining portfolio that you're withdrawing each year.
This doesn't mean every retiree needs to cut spending whenever stocks fall 10%.
Markets regularly fluctuate.
But if you're experiencing a significant or prolonged decline and your withdrawal rate begins climbing to an unsustainable level, some temporary flexibility can make a meaningful difference.
That's why I prefer building flexibility into the retirement plan before it's needed.
Prefer to Watch MY YouTube Video on This Topic? — Click Here
4. Look for Tax Opportunities During a Market Decline
A stock market crash isn't something any investor wants.
But declining markets can occasionally create tax-planning opportunities.
Suppose you have money in several types of accounts:
Traditional IRA
401(k)
Roth IRA
Taxable brokerage account
Normally, perhaps you're taking most of your retirement withdrawals from a traditional IRA.
Those distributions are generally taxable as ordinary income.
During a market decline, however, you might have investments in a taxable brokerage account that have fallen in value.
Depending on your individual tax situation, selling investments from the taxable account could generate a smaller capital gain—or potentially a capital loss.
That could make the taxable account a more attractive source for some of your spending than taking additional fully taxable IRA distributions.
This is why retirement withdrawal planning shouldn't always follow a rigid formula.
The most tax-efficient account to withdraw from can change from one year to the next.
Tax-Loss Harvesting During a Market Decline
Market declines can also create opportunities for tax-loss harvesting in taxable investment accounts.
If an investment is worth less than what you originally paid for it, selling it may realize a capital loss.
Those losses can potentially be used to offset capital gains, subject to applicable tax rules.
If losses exceed gains, a limited amount may also potentially offset ordinary income, with additional unused losses generally carried forward to future tax years.
However, tax-loss harvesting needs to be handled carefully, including consideration of the wash-sale rules.
A market decline doesn't automatically mean you should sell investments simply to generate losses.
The transaction should still make sense within your overall investment and tax strategy.
5. Consider Roth Conversions When the Market Is Down
One of the most interesting opportunities during a major market decline can be a Roth conversion.
Suppose you own an investment inside your traditional IRA that was previously worth:
$100,000
The market falls 25%, and it's now worth:
$75,000
If you were already considering converting that investment to a Roth IRA, the lower market value could allow you to convert the same number of shares while recognizing less taxable income than you would have before the decline.
If the investment subsequently recovers inside the Roth IRA, that future growth could potentially occur tax-free, assuming applicable Roth distribution requirements are satisfied.
This can make market downturns an attractive time to at least evaluate Roth conversions.
Don't Do a Roth Conversion Just Because the Market Is Down
A lower stock market isn't enough by itself to justify a Roth conversion.
You still need to consider:
Your current federal tax bracket
Expected future tax brackets
State income taxes
Social Security taxation
Medicare IRMAA
Required minimum distributions
Available cash to pay the conversion tax
Estate-planning goals
Your overall retirement-income strategy
A market decline may make the mathematics of a conversion more attractive, but the conversion still needs to fit your broader tax plan.
Should You Sell Everything If the Stock Market Crashes?
For most long-term investors, panicking and selling everything after a major decline can create another problem:
You then have to decide when to get back into the market.
That's extraordinarily difficult.
Selling after stocks have already fallen can lock in losses.
If the market then recovers quickly, you could miss part of the recovery while sitting in cash.
That's why your asset allocation should ideally be designed before a market crash around a level of risk you're capable of tolerating.
If you own a diversified portfolio and your long-term plan hasn't changed, declining markets don't necessarily mean your investment strategy is broken.
They may simply mean you're experiencing the downside that comes with accepting investment risk.
Should Retirees Still Own Stocks?
Retirement doesn't mean your investment time horizon suddenly falls to zero.
Someone retiring at 60 or 65 could potentially need their portfolio to provide income for another 25 or 30 years—or longer.
Over such a long retirement, inflation can significantly increase the cost of maintaining your lifestyle.
That's one reason stocks can continue to play an important role in a retirement portfolio.
The goal isn't necessarily to eliminate investment risk.
It's to take an appropriate amount of risk while maintaining enough liquidity and conservative investments to meet shorter-term spending needs.
Should You Delay Retirement If the Stock Market Crashes?
This is a much more personal question.
If the stock market crashes shortly before your planned retirement date, that doesn't automatically mean you need to keep working.
But it is a good reason to rerun your retirement projections.
Ask:
Can my portfolio still support my planned withdrawals?
Has my withdrawal rate become too high?
Do I have sufficient conservative investments?
Can I temporarily reduce discretionary spending?
Should my Social Security strategy change?
Are there tax-planning opportunities?
Am I comfortable with my current asset allocation?
What happens if the market takes several years to recover?
This is especially important for someone retiring in their late 50s or early 60s.
Once you leave the workforce, returning to a comparable job may become more difficult.
You want to be confident that your retirement plan isn't dependent on the stock market performing perfectly during your first several years.
How to Prepare for a Stock Market Crash Before Retirement
If you're approaching retirement, don't make predicting the next crash your goal.
Instead, stress-test your retirement plan.
Consider what would happen if your portfolio fell:
10%
20%
25%
or even:
30%+
Then determine how your retirement income strategy would respond.
Would you draw from cash?
Would you use short-term bonds?
Could you reduce discretionary spending?
Could you temporarily change which account you're withdrawing from?
Would a Roth conversion make sense?
Most importantly:
Would your retirement plan still work?
Knowing those answers before the market declines can help you make rational decisions when everyone else is reacting emotionally.
5 Ways to Prepare Your Retirement for a Market Crash
To recap, here are five strategies to consider:
1. Maintain Conservative Investments for Near-Term Withdrawals
Consider maintaining sufficient cash, short-term bonds, CDs, or similar investments to help fund expenses without being forced to sell stocks during a downturn.
2. Review Your Asset Allocation
Understand how much your portfolio could realistically decline and whether you're financially and emotionally prepared for that loss.
3. Build Flexibility Into Your Spending
Separate essential expenses from discretionary spending so you know where you could temporarily adjust if necessary.
4. Look for Tax-Planning Opportunities
Evaluate which accounts you're withdrawing from and whether strategies such as tax-loss harvesting could improve your tax situation.
5. Evaluate Roth Conversions
Lower market values can potentially create attractive Roth-conversion opportunities, particularly when combined with favorable tax circumstances.
Final Thoughts
A stock market crash immediately after retirement can be frightening.
But a market decline doesn't automatically mean your retirement is ruined.
The real danger comes from entering retirement without understanding sequence of returns risk and without having a strategy for what you'll do when markets inevitably decline.
You can't control when the next bear market happens.
You can control:
How your portfolio is allocated.
Where your next several years of withdrawals will come from.
How flexible your spending can be.
How you manage your taxes.
And how you respond when markets fall.
Market declines have happened throughout history, and they'll happen again.
Your retirement plan shouldn't require you to predict them.
It should be built to withstand them.
Have a great week—and I’ll talk to you next Tuesday.
Written by Ryan Morrissey CFP®, CLU®, CHFC®, CMFC
Founder & Principal Advisor of Morrissey Wealth Management
Host of the Retire with Ryan Podcast
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Frequently Asked Questions
What happens if the stock market crashes right after I retire?
A stock market crash early in retirement can be particularly damaging because you may be withdrawing money while your investments are declining. This creates sequence of returns risk. A diversified portfolio, conservative assets for near-term withdrawals, flexible spending, and a coordinated withdrawal strategy can help manage this risk.
What is sequence of returns risk?
Sequence of returns risk is the risk that poor investment returns occur early in retirement while you're withdrawing money from your portfolio. Selling investments after they've declined can leave fewer assets available to participate in a future market recovery.
Should I retire when the stock market is at an all-time high?
Stock market levels alone shouldn't determine your retirement date. Instead, evaluate whether your retirement plan can withstand a significant market decline shortly after you retire.
Should I sell my stocks before I retire?
Not necessarily. Retirees may still need long-term growth from stocks to support decades of retirement spending and help keep pace with inflation. Your appropriate allocation depends on your spending needs, income sources, risk tolerance, time horizon, and overall financial plan.
How much cash should I have before retirement?
There isn't one appropriate amount for every retiree. Your cash and conservative investment allocation should consider your expected portfolio withdrawals, Social Security and pension income, other assets, risk tolerance, and retirement-income plan.
Should I stop withdrawing money when the market crashes?
Not necessarily. You still need income to live. However, having conservative investments available and keeping some discretionary spending flexible may help reduce the need to sell depreciated stock investments.
Should I do a Roth conversion when the stock market falls?
A market decline can create an attractive Roth-conversion opportunity because investments may be converted at lower values. However, you should also consider your tax bracket, Medicare IRMAA, Social Security taxation, future required minimum distributions, and long-term tax strategy.
Should I delay retirement if the stock market crashes?
Not automatically. Instead, rerun your retirement projections to determine whether your portfolio can still support your desired spending and withstand a prolonged downturn.